For the first time in the Scorecard’s history, more Americans live in A states than in F states
During the same week President Trump’s State of the Union failed to detail a gun safety agenda, 2019 Scorecard reveals state leaders continue making unprecedented progress
February 6, 2020 — Giffords Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence released its Annual Gun Law Scorecard, an analysis that grades and ranks each state on the strength of its gun laws—revealing that fewer people die from gun violence in states with strong gun laws. The 50-state analysis found that for the first time in the history of the Gun Law Scorecard, more Americans live in A states (98.7 million) than in F states (94.7 million).
Just days after President Donald Trump gave a State of the Union speech where he failed to detail a gun safety agenda, the Scorecard proves that state lawmakers continue to make lifesaving progress in passing stronger gun laws. Since the tragic shooting in Parkland, Florida, states have passed more than 135 gun safety laws. In 2019 alone, 22 states and the District of Columbia signed 70 gun safety bills into law.
“The president and Senate have an established track record of following the NRA’s orders. Meanwhile, state lawmakers are charting a different course, passing hundreds of laws that have brought countless communities increased peace and safety,” said Robyn Thomas, executive director of Giffords Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence. “The rise of gun safety laws, which accelerated after Parkland captured the nation’s attention and crystalized demands for action shows that leaders on both sides of the aisle are taking action. Looking to the states that made improvements over the past year demonstrates that more legislatures are awakening to the fact that the time to act is now. However with 21 states still earning F grades, it’s clear we have work to do. The light we shined on trafficking this year proves that as many states move forward, it’s time for the federal government to step up and do more to protect residents of every state from the risk of gun violence. Year after year, it is our intention to show legislators, activists, and citizens that progress is possible. We hope they use the Gun Law Scorecard to evaluate the safety of their state and make informed choices that will lead to a safer America.”
Giffords Law Center’s Annual Gun Law Scorecard underscores the fact that gun laws save lives in the states that work to enact them. This progress is making a lasting impact across the country. For the first time in the history of the Gun Law Scorecard, more Americans live in A states (98.7 million) than F states (94.7 million.) Between 2012 and 2019, the number of Americans living in states with A grades increased by more than 45 million, while the number of people living in states with D and F grades declined.
Many places around the country where progress was once thought improbable have seen marked improvements in the past year. For example, after the election of a new governor in New Mexico with a mandate to pass stronger gun laws, the state saw a dramatic shift in its grade—moving from an F to a C as a package of bills was passed to strengthen background checks and disarm domestic abusers.
While last year saw 70 gun safety bills signed into law in 22 states and DC, the changes in seven states were significant enough to raise these states’ grades:
Illinois (B+ to an A-): Passed comprehensive gun dealer regulations
Colorado (C to a C+): Passed an extreme risk protection order
Nevada (D to a C+): Passed universal background checks, an extreme risk protection order law, a bump stock ban, and a child access prevention law
Nebraska (C- to a C): Directed funding to proven community violence intervention strategies
New Mexico (F to a C): Passed background checks and enacted a domestic violence law
Vermont (D+ to a C-): Received additional points for its previously enacted domestic violence law
Utah (D- to a D): Passed a bill requiring more reporting of prohibited purchaser records to NICS
2019 Gun Law Scorecard Spotlight: Firearms Trafficking
The 2019 Annual Gun Law Scorecard also takes a close look at the impact firearms trafficking has on undermining state gun laws. The United States suffers from an inconsistent patchwork of state laws—allowing guns to move easily from states with weak gun laws into those with stronger regulations. Notably, eight of the 10 states that traffic firearms at the highest rates have F grades.
California, for example, has the strongest gun laws in the nation. Neighboring states with weaker gun laws fuel gun crime and violence in the state by contributing to the more than 10,000 guns trafficked into California each year.
Similar situations occur in other states with strong gun laws, like Illinois and Maryland. Nearly half of the guns used in crime in Illinois—and nearly 60% of the guns used in crime in Chicago—are trafficked in from states with weaker gun laws. Most of these guns come from Indiana, which lacks many of the important gun safety protections Illinois has passed. Southern states with F grades, like Missouri, Kentucky, and Mississippi, also traffic hundreds of crime guns into Illinois each year.
In Maryland, the state with the highest rate of crime gun imports, traffickers bring nearly three times as many gus into Maryland compared to the state average. Maryland sits within what is known as the Iron Pipeline, a route used to traffic firearms from Southern states with weak gun laws to Northeastern states with stronger laws. Nearly a third of crime guns used in Maryland were originally sold in Virginia. Guns from Georgia and Florida are also major contributors to gun crime in the state.
Until we pass strong federal gun safety laws, the lifesaving strides made by states like California, Illinois, and Maryland will continue to be jeopardized by neighboring states with weak gun laws, leaving all Americans at greater risk of gun violence.
Visit the Annual Gun Law Scorecard at gunlawscorecard.org.
Experts Available for Comment
Robyn Thomas, Executive Director, Giffords Law Center
Laura Cutilletta, Managing Director, Giffords Law Center
Allison Anderman, Senior Counsel, Giffords Law Center